Search This Blog

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Reputation in Financial Services

On the 29th of June, I’ve been to a very interesting conference, “Reputation in Financial Services”, well organised by Communicate magazine.

I was quite curious to attend as financial services has been – after oil – the most battered sector in terms of trust, reputation…in a nutshell, credibility.

Even though the initial scepticism, I must say that the excellent quality of the speakers almost convinced me that something is changing in the way financial services now approach their customers. I mean, less cash cows and more human beings.

To whom speak about passions, values, love. It sounds cheesy but consider this: as the study by Uffindell pointed out, Apple has been able to create a relationship with their customers based on “love and passion”. 
Jillian Fransen, Barclays Bank
Banks, on the other side, are struggling to invite their customers for a “romantic dinner”. Financial sectors customers indeed seems to constantly looking for the best deal and for them is not really problematic to jump from one bank to another. Banks need to become “sexy & accountable”, and I have to say that banks, in this case, are the only entities to be blamed for this customers’ attitude.

ING was very inspirational: Adrian Simpson, Head of UK Corporate Comms at ING, has outlined the necessity to build a new paradigm in the sector, based on new values. 

Mike Tyrrell, SRI Connect
Banks and financial institutions need to start listening their customers and understanding their real needs and values in this current difficult contingency that the entire world is living. Banks have a responsibility in the community. ING seems to be pretty careful about this topic and his innovation about the use of social media is a clear testimonial.
Personally, I thought that Adrian’s commitment and enthusiasm to topic was pretty interesting to hear. It looked like the sector has started actively to look for new solutions in line with the most innovative consumer trends.
Mr Simpson has obviously underlined also the critical role of CSR as a tool to engage, internally and externally the stakeholders of his company. “ING has the responsibility to do good” has said. The vision he outlined for ING confirmed that acting responsibly would pay off not just in reputation but also in a greater satisfaction of employees that would be likely to be more productive. 
By looking back at Social Media, Adrian has suggested also their importance in their current CSR activities. “We love to speak to our public about our Social Commitment and we would like to engage them in our day by day results”.

Interesting indeed.
Interesting session has been also the one run by Rob Challis from Tangent Synergy about to what extent CSR can be useful to increase the corporate reputation level. Rob has underlined the importance for each company to understand the non-financial risk factors that could undermine corporate performance. 


A big thanks to Liz Foggitt, author of these great shots and to Alberto Campora for his indispensable contribution!

Friday, June 24, 2011

Is nuclear the only alternative? A view from The Economist

On Thursday this week, I’ve been to the Economist UK Energy conference which included some of the most prominent personalities in the world of energy.
CEOs from Centrica, RWE power, Johnson Mathhey together with several academics, helped us all to understand where UK is going in order to cope with the ever increasing demand of energy and if there’s a real alternative today to nuclear power.
I will post later on new interesting videos, in the meantime check this out

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Trust and marketing

Hi all,

I found this very interesting article on Business Respect, which makes a very good point about the misuse of trust and the marketing intelligence when about campaigning to peers.
Very interesting.

"The language of trust is, as far as I can see, the common language between marketers and corporate social responsibility teams. By and large, they have very different perspectives on the dynamics of business but the one thing they will agree on – if you lose trust, your job just got a lot harder.


So one of the core skills of either group, therefore, should be to understand how to build trust with key constituencies. One problem. Trust is not a fixed reference point – a reliable outcome from a set of practiced techniques. It changes and evolves over time.

For instance, the latest version of the Edelman Trust Barometer suggests that there have been significant shifts in who trusts whom since the last one. The headlines tend to focus on how much business is trusted, how much government is trusted and so on.

One of the things I found most remarkable was this: Over the last year people's trust in their friends as a source of information or recommendations has dropped dramatically – from 45 percent in 2009 to 25 percent in 2010.

Let's put aside the suspicion that our most reliable friends have deserted us en mass during the last year and focus on what this means.

It means that the revolution of online social networking – and the engagement by marketers of the same – has had an effect – and not the one that was generally anticipated.

Companies such as Amazon pioneered the use of peer–recommendation, by introducing customer reviews of products. Then came Facebook where you gathered about yourself the online expressions of your closest trusted friends.

And marketers came to understand that the language of trust worked best through people we know and like. So they started aiming to utilise approaches that would get people recommending their experiences to those friends. They focused on things they could use to 'go viral'. The focused on ideas that would spread.

The result has been the same as any where a previously strong technique has been widely adopted, imitated and exploited – diminishing returns.

Now, suddenly, people are finding that their friends are just as susceptible as they themselves are – and that their recommendations don't always hold true. So trust is going down. 

Yet another triumph for the world of marketing.

Marketers are already responding by saying that they shouldn't rely too heavily on peer to peer marketing as its power is reducing. There doesn't seem to be any particular reflection on the causal chain there, though.

The so–called blogosphere doesn't score well, either, by the way. Trust in information from blogs and other free–content sources like Wikipedia is very low – below 22 percent trust information from these sources.

That is only realistic. But as with all things, there will be individual sources that become more highly trusted than others over time. You might think, therefore, that trust in traditional media is on the rise. Since we have become disillusioned with the self–appointed commentators (what, me?) and our rather gullible friends, we are probably ready to pay for news we can trust again. 

Nope. Trust in media companies is still on the way down. TV news plummeted 20 points. Newspapers by 14 points. 

It's interesting, because most 'social media gurus' (and there seem to be thousands of self–appointed gurus – but at least a few are widely respected) tend to argue that businesses need to engage in social media as a way to build trust. They have to be "part of the conversation" on Twitter and on blogs. They should be responding, and promoting their message – in an authentic fashion – through those channels.

And yet it could be that it is the increasing number of companies doing precisely that which is resulting in this growing lack of trust.

The point is that you have to be aware of the action – reaction cycle when it comes to building trust. Ultimately, the ability to build trust doesn't depend so much on which channels you use, but whether you show that you genuinely care about the outcomes you have on people, and show yourself to be trustworthy by delivering on your promises.

What you do changes the nature of the thing you do it to.

If you take something, like 'hours spent on training', which is generally an indicator of good things happening – and then you make it into a target, it changes the nature of the thing. Suddenly, people have an incentive to create new training courses to clock up those all–important brownie points, and after a while you realise that you're capturing the quantity of training, not the quality of outcome.

So it is here. Engage with social media, and you are part of the process that is changing social media.

It's not a problem so long as you look after people and deliver on your promises. Unfortunately, the majority of marketing engagement with social media either does not pass this test or, at the very least, is not perceived to pass this test.

Too late now. The well is poisoned – at least in part.

By the way, trust in NGOs continues to rise. Why? Surely in part because they are seen as being motivated by the common good, and even though some of them may engage with companies they haven't yet been co–opted as a channel for marketing – cause marketing (a minority sport) notwithstanding.

This might make for a fascinating conversation between CSR teams and marketing teams, by the way. "

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Is birth control the ultimate strategy to save the planet?

I know this could be thought-provoking but...
The Eastern part of the world is quickly gaining ground in terms of wealth, increased and better lifestyle, higher spending consumption...but it's not just the few hundred millions of the Western Europe or the North America...here it's about billions.
Nowadays we're sucking up about 1.5x the resources of the planet...to figure out how it could be when those billions increase their lifestyle up to Western standards...well...either makes me shiver or think like a catastrophist.
Have a read to this article I found in the Guardian and let me know what you think...comments are open just below this post.

In the meantime, enjoy this one...

Friday, April 15, 2011

CSR strategy: where are we?

I took the lead from an interesting book from Wayne Visser, to make a step back in what I'm currently doing and think "where we stand". 
Sometimes too often, living the corporate life like it is the centre of the universe or living our mission as CSR officers just as employees and not as people leading the change from within, makes us go like those poor horses with their eyes blinded. Missing completely the target.


Your comments are welcome, either here or on linkedin!

So...where are you?

1. Defensive CSR
The Age of Greed is characterised by Defensive CSR in which all corporate sustainability and responsibility practices – which are typically limited - are undertaken only if and when it can be shown that shareholder value will be protected as a result. Hence, employee volunteer programmes (which show evidence of improved staff motivation, commitment and productivity) are not uncommon, nor are expenditures (for example in pollution controls) which are seen to fend off regulation or avoid fines and penalties.

2. Charitable CSR
Charitable CSR in the Age of Philanthropy is where a company supports various social and environmental causes through donations and sponsorships, typically administered through a Foundation, Trust or Chairman’s Fund and aimed at empowering community groups or civil society organisations.

3. Promotional CSR
Promotional CSR in the Age of Misdirection is what happens when corporate sustainability and responsibility is seen mainly as a public relations opportunity to enhance the brand, image and reputation of the company. Promotional CSR may draw on the practices of Charitable and Strategic CSR and turn them into PR spin, which is often characterised as ‘greenwash’.
4. Strategic CSR
Strategic CSR, emerging from the Age of Management, means relating CSR activities to the company’s core business (e.g. Coca-Cola and water management), often through adherence to CSR codes and implementation of social and environmental management systems, which typically involve cycles of CSR policy development, goal and target setting, programme implementation, auditing and reporting.

5. Systemic CSR

Systemic CSR in the Age of Responsibility focuses its activities on identifying and tackling the root causes of our present unsustainability and irresponsibility, typically through innovating business models, revolutionising their processes, products and services and lobbying for progressive national and international policies.

If you want more...just have a look at this (even if it's not the most interesting piece of video in the world I must admit...!)





Saturday, March 26, 2011

Share the change, share the value

The capitalist system is under siege. In recent years business increasingly has been viewed as a major cause of social, environmental, and economic problems. Companies are widely perceived to be prospering at the expense of the broader community.

Even worse, the more business has begun to embrace corporate responsibility, the more it has been blamed for society’s failures. The legitimacy of business has fallen to levels not seen in recent history. This diminished trust in business leads political leaders to set policies that undermine competitiveness and sap economic growth. Business is caught in a vicious circle.

A big part of the problem lies with companies themselves, which remain trapped in an outdated approach to value creation that has emerged over the past few decades. They continue to view value creation narrowly, optimizing short-term financial performance in a bubble while missing the most important customer needs and ignoring the broader influences that determine their longer-term success.
How else could companies overlook the well-being of their customers, the depletion of natural resources vital to their businesses, the viability of key suppliers, or the economic distress of the communities in which they produce and sell? How else could companies think that simply shifting activities to locations with ever lower wages was a sustainable “solution” to competitive challenges?

Government and civil society have often exacerbated the problem by attempting to address social weaknesses at the expense of business. The presumed trade-offs between economic efficiency and social progress have been institutionalized in decades of policy choices.

Companies must take the lead in bringing business and society back together. The recognition is there among sophisticated business and thought leaders, and promising elements of a new model are emerging. Yet we still lack an overall framework for guiding these efforts, and most companies remain stuck in a “social responsibility” mind-set in which societal issues are at the periphery, not the core.

The solution lies in the principle of shared value, which involves creating economic value in a way that also creates value for society by addressing its needs and challenges. Businesses must reconnect company success with social progress.

Shared value is not social responsibility, philanthropy, or even sustainability, but a new way to achieve economic success. It is not on the margin of what companies do but at the center.
We believe that it can give rise to the next major transformation of business thinking. And something is already happening (www.watchfyi.tv).


Thursday, March 10, 2011

Are consumers buying sustainability? (part II)

In my previous post I spoke about why the consumer social agenda is so important. But what I'm now following up is the main concept that drives people's behaviour. It's ETHICS.

And due to the importance of such a value and its place in the "consumer mindset", an ignorance of ethical behaviour can be catastrophic for a company and its brand. Take Nike for example: in the 1990s news emerged that the sports equipment manufacturer was using child labour in the developing world to produce a range of footballs. A public campaign exploded – and this was before the days of widespread Internet use, viral communications and social networking – that caused the discerning public to boycott Nike goods and the activist public to demonstrate outside its retail outlets. Sales for Nike goods dropped away, and the share price tumbled, elucidating uncomfortable questions from the sports company’s institutional investors.

It still took time for Nike’s reputation, and share price to recover.



And today the relevance of such social and environmental issues is as strong as never before. Are consumers buying sustainability?

Yes, and in increasing numbers. Consumers are buying it, both notionally andat the tills. Mainstream awareness and concern exists and behaviours are changing. Consumers want to act and buy more sustainably, but are restricted by three key barriers – high price; confusion and lack of trust; and availability of alternatives.
What’s the result then? People are changing lifestyle and behaviours.



Today’s consumers know, and care more about what they buy, how it is made, what it is made from, how far it travels and how it is packaged. The way consumers gather and share information has also changed; they are empowered and linked as never before by the internet. Information can spread globally in an instant. The consequences of being found to be operating unethically, or in an environmentally unfriendly manner, as said in my previous post, can be damaging and long-term.


Some might argue the hype will exceed the reality in the short term. However, rather as the internet is revolutionizing retail, sustainability is an issue which will change the world.
Retail and consumer goods companies need to prepare now.







(written with John Foster)